• About   |
  • Write For Us   |
  • Contact Us   |
  • हिंदी
Tuesday, February 7, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
The Second Angle
Advertise
  • Infotainment
    • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
      • Home & Decoration
  • People
    • Inspiring
  • Education
  • Travel
  • Finance
  • Healthcare
  • Technology
  • World
The Second Angle
  • Infotainment
  • Entertainment
  • People
  • Education
  • Travel
  • Finance
  • Healthcare
  • Technology
  • World
Advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT
Home News

‘Redact sensitive portion’: Supreme Court gives a way out of sealed cover affidavits

TSA Desk by TSA Desk
November 6, 2022
in News
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
Share on FacebookShare on WhatsApp
Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT


The court says the government can redact the sensitive portions and show the rest to the petitioners

RelatedPosts

With Glazers possibly out, check some of United’s potential buyers

With Glazers possibly out, check some of United’s potential buyers

Bar Council of T.N. & Puducherry suspends 9 lawyers from practicing before any forum

The court says the government can redact the sensitive portions and show the rest to the petitioners

The Supreme Court has suggested a way out of routinely filing documents in sealed covers, especially in cases touching on national security. The court said the government could redact the sensitive portions and show the rest to the petitioners. This would address both the state’s concerns about “national security” and the “right to know” of petitioners.

In cases where the government insists on keeping materials confidential from petitioners in public interest, it ought to claim “specific privilege” in an affidavit and impress upon the court that the contents should remain confidential.

The suggestion came from a Bench of Justices D.Y. Chandrachud and Hima Kohli, which said the government has to present “extenuating circumstances” before confidentially passing materials to the court without disclosing them to the petitioners.

The observations came during a hearing on the challenge to the telecast ban on the Kerala-based Media One TV channel. The government wanted to pass on its internal files in a sealed cover. It did not want to share the contents with the media company whose security clearance was revoked in January on the grounds of “national security and public order” without specifying any further details. The media company argued that passing on materials in a sealed cover to the court would compel the judges to accept the state’s version, that too, in cases in which the government’s narrative is under challenge and the fundamental rights of the petitioners are at stake.

“What is so great that you cannot share even the redacted files with them (media company)? You have to impress upon us what would be in the files, the disclosure of which to the other party would affect national security,” Justice Chandrachud orally addressed the government before reserving the case for judgment on November 3.

The question heralds a turn in the tide in a court which has in the past entertained sealed covers even while efforts were on to embrace the concept of ‘open court’ through live-streaming proceedings. Sealed covers were unquestioningly accepted, even sought for in cases, including the purchase of Rafale jets, the Bhima Koregaon case, the National Register of Citizens in Assam, the Board of Control for Cricket in India, and the anticipatory bail plea for former Union Finance Minister P. Chidambaram. In these cases, sealed cover even rose to the status of due procedure.

However, a counter-thought against the routine passing on of sealed covers in violation of natural justice has persisted in the Supreme Court as is evident through a small clutch of judgments. These verdicts highlight the right to information as an important facet of the right to freedom of speech and expression. They said that a democracy sworn to transparency and accountability should necessarily respect the right of an individual to know. The state cannot “take away these rights in an implied fashion or in casual and cavalier manner”.

Editorial | Sealed justice: On sealed cover jurisprudence

The most recent one was in the S.P. Velumani case verdict of May 2022 in which the Supreme Court criticised the Madras High Court’s decision to permit a report to remain “shrouded in sealed cover” when the State had not even claimed any specific privilege.

In Anuradha Bhasin, the court said sensitive portions in government records “can be redacted or such material can be claimed as privileged, if the state justifies such redaction on the grounds, as allowed under the law”.

In the Ram Jethmalani case judgment, the court said the state is obliged to disclose information in cases in which petitioners seek the protection of fundamental rights. “It is imperative that in such proceedings the petitioners are not denied the information necessary for them to properly articulate the case and be heard, especially where such information is in the possession of the state.”

In the P. Chidambaram case, the court held that “it would be against the concept of fair trial if in every case the prosecution presents documents in sealed cover and the findings on the same are recorded as if the offence is committed and the same is treated as having a bearing for denial or grant of bail”.

ShareSendTweet
TSA Desk

TSA Desk

Related Posts

With Glazers possibly out, check some of United’s potential buyers
Sports

With Glazers possibly out, check some of United’s potential buyers

One of the biggest stories on sports pages at the end of 2022, The American Glazer family, who are the...

Read more
News

Bar Council of T.N. & Puducherry suspends 9 lawyers from practicing before any forum

Photograph used for representational purposes only The Bar Council of Tamil Nadu and Puducherry (BCTNP) on Tuesday notified the suspension...

Read more
News

Kerala government agrees to debate Vizhinjam port agitation and related violence in the Assembly

An injured police personnel being shifted to a hospital after a mob of agitators attacked Vizhinjam police station following the...

Read more
News

Decisive G20 not possible without support of members, says Amitabh Kant

India’s G-20 Sherpa Amitabh Kant speaks at the first G20 Sherpa meeting, in Udaipur, on December 4. | Photo Credit:...

Read more
News

CBI moves Delhi HC challenging statutory bail granted to DHFL’s Wadhawan brothers

Dewan Housing Finance Corporation Limited The CBI on Monday approached the Delhi High Court challenging the statutory bail granted to...

Read more
News

Andhra Pradesh: We are working towards making Chittoor a major industrial hub, says Collector

Chittoor District Collector M. Hari Narayanan speaking to The Hindu on Monday. | Photo Credit: BY ARRANGEMENT Chittoor district holds...

Read more
Load More
Next Post

Morning Digest | November 6, 2022

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Facebook Twitter Instagram Telegram

About

The Second Angle

A platform providing diverse views on various issues, providing an in-depth understanding of important developments happening around us. It offers you true journalism amidst the cacophony. Discover the latest news, opinions, analysis and a lot more here.

Important Links

  • About
  • Career
  • Write for us | The Second Angle
  • Support Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • हिंदी

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

© 2017-22. The Second Angle. All Rights Reserved. Developed and Maintenance by SquareBase.io

No Result
View All Result
  • Infotainment
    • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
      • Home & Decoration
  • People
    • Inspiring
  • Education
  • Travel
  • Finance
  • Healthcare
  • Technology
  • World
  • Login
  • Sign Up

© 2017-22. The Second Angle. All Rights Reserved. Developed and Maintenance by SquareBase.io

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
Go to mobile version